Commentary
by Jeff Poor
Old conventional wisdom exists for those who made the unfortunate decision to spend any part of their life living in or around Washington, D.C.
That is, Republicans live in Virginia, and Democrats live in the District of Columbia and Maryland.
That isn’t true anymore, as the federal government’s business has created one of the most affluent suburbs in human history.
Still, while the center of gravity for NOVA (Northern Virginia) is Washington, D.C., ROVA (the rest of Virginia) dictated the area’s politics for years.
Now, so goes Northern Virginia, so goes Richmond, the state’s capital, as Arlington, Alexandria, Fairfax, Loudoun and Prince William counties make up a significant portion of the state’s overall population.
Those counties now have a population whose occupations rely on the federal government, be it lobbyists, contractors, lawyers or government employees.
Suffice it to say, in that sector, the economy isn’t churning out many people with a Ron Paul libertarian mindset. If your occupation is connected to the federal government, you’re likely to have an inherent belief in the power of government as a force for good, or, at a minimum, in your livelihood.
That mindset translates into a lot of Democratic votes, which is part of why Virginia went from a culturally southern state to more of a Mid-Atlantic state.
Politically, Virginia is mostly lost for Republicans. Virginians will elect a Republican governor. However, that usually requires a Democrat in the White House with animosity by the loyal opposition party.
Back home in Alabama, former Senator Richard Shelby’s 1990s vision for Huntsville is becoming a reality.
The federal government is relocating massive bureaucracies from the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area to other parts of the country. This has been done under Trump’s Republican administration at the behest of Republicans on Capitol Hill with the stated purpose of deconstructing the administrative state and its groupthink, which has been referred to as of late as the so-called “Deep State.”
Huntsville was a likely target, given it is the home of Redstone Arsenal and has a long-standing association with space exploration and rocket building.
As a result, government contractors with headquarters along the Dulles Toll Road in Northern Virginia now have outposts on Research Park Blvd. They employ thousands and will likely increase their footprint as the federal government expands its operations in North Alabama.
North Alabama is booming much like Northern Virginia has over the past 50 years. Farmland in Madison and Limestone Counties is giving way to development. The culture is shifting from something that resembles anywhere else in the South to something more like the Washington, D.C. suburbs.
Unfortunately for the GOP, so are the politics.
Six months ago, it seemed like a trend Republicans in those areas could weather. Transient populations are hardly as engaged in local politics as the multi-generational population that has been mostly Republican for more than a decade.
After all, this is the same congressional district that reelected Mo Brooks multiple times. Now, that same Mo Brooks literally could not even win a Republican primary for a state legislative seat in the heart of that congressional district.
This could be a real problem for Republicans next month. What was supposed to be a passing fad, with some swing voters out of sorts with the current Trump administration, causing nothing more than some anxious moments, could be the prelude to a blue wave.
Early polling indicates Madison County voters are ready to show their disapproval of President Donald Trump and hit the straight-ticket vote for Doug Jones and everything else down the ballot.
Unlike Northern Virginia, we are not quite at the point where so goes Huntsville, so goes Montgomery. But some long-time Republican-held legislative seats are under serious threat from insurgent Democrats.
Yes, the modern Huntsville that Richard Shelby envisioned decades ago is becoming a reality, but it favors the Democratic Party, Shelby’s former political party.
This seemingly overnight flip from Republican to Democrat shows how fragile political majorities can be under certain circumstances.
Trump won Madison County by nine points in 2024. However, if you pair new voters who brought their politics with them with an overall malaise and resentment toward the current Republican administration, a county could flip in a matter of months.
At worst, Republicans could lose three or four legislative seats. Incumbent U.S. Rep. Dale Strong (R-Huntsville) could also have a long night ahead if some of the outlying boxes in his district don’t turn out.
Changing the culture and economy of a part of your state comes with a political price. Sure, you might get a windfall in tax receipts, new customers for local businesses, etc.
When the government tries to boost the local economy, as the GOP-controlled state and federal governments have, there are intended consequences, and unintended consequences can be felt across the state.
Jeff Poor
The Northern Virginia-ing of North Alabama
Commentary
by Jeff Poor
Old conventional wisdom exists for those who made the unfortunate decision to spend any part of their life living in or around Washington, D.C.
That is, Republicans live in Virginia, and Democrats live in the District of Columbia and Maryland.
That isn’t true anymore, as the federal government’s business has created one of the most affluent suburbs in human history.
Still, while the center of gravity for NOVA (Northern Virginia) is Washington, D.C., ROVA (the rest of Virginia) dictated the area’s politics for years.
Now, so goes Northern Virginia, so goes Richmond, the state’s capital, as Arlington, Alexandria, Fairfax, Loudoun and Prince William counties make up a significant portion of the state’s overall population.
Those counties now have a population whose occupations rely on the federal government, be it lobbyists, contractors, lawyers or government employees.
Suffice it to say, in that sector, the economy isn’t churning out many people with a Ron Paul libertarian mindset. If your occupation is connected to the federal government, you’re likely to have an inherent belief in the power of government as a force for good, or, at a minimum, in your livelihood.
That mindset translates into a lot of Democratic votes, which is part of why Virginia went from a culturally southern state to more of a Mid-Atlantic state.
Politically, Virginia is mostly lost for Republicans. Virginians will elect a Republican governor. However, that usually requires a Democrat in the White House with animosity by the loyal opposition party.
Back home in Alabama, former Senator Richard Shelby’s 1990s vision for Huntsville is becoming a reality.
The federal government is relocating massive bureaucracies from the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area to other parts of the country. This has been done under Trump’s Republican administration at the behest of Republicans on Capitol Hill with the stated purpose of deconstructing the administrative state and its groupthink, which has been referred to as of late as the so-called “Deep State.”
Huntsville was a likely target, given it is the home of Redstone Arsenal and has a long-standing association with space exploration and rocket building.
As a result, government contractors with headquarters along the Dulles Toll Road in Northern Virginia now have outposts on Research Park Blvd. They employ thousands and will likely increase their footprint as the federal government expands its operations in North Alabama.
North Alabama is booming much like Northern Virginia has over the past 50 years. Farmland in Madison and Limestone Counties is giving way to development. The culture is shifting from something that resembles anywhere else in the South to something more like the Washington, D.C. suburbs.
Unfortunately for the GOP, so are the politics.
Six months ago, it seemed like a trend Republicans in those areas could weather. Transient populations are hardly as engaged in local politics as the multi-generational population that has been mostly Republican for more than a decade.
After all, this is the same congressional district that reelected Mo Brooks multiple times. Now, that same Mo Brooks literally could not even win a Republican primary for a state legislative seat in the heart of that congressional district.
This could be a real problem for Republicans next month. What was supposed to be a passing fad, with some swing voters out of sorts with the current Trump administration, causing nothing more than some anxious moments, could be the prelude to a blue wave.
Early polling indicates Madison County voters are ready to show their disapproval of President Donald Trump and hit the straight-ticket vote for Doug Jones and everything else down the ballot.
Unlike Northern Virginia, we are not quite at the point where so goes Huntsville, so goes Montgomery. But some long-time Republican-held legislative seats are under serious threat from insurgent Democrats.
Yes, the modern Huntsville that Richard Shelby envisioned decades ago is becoming a reality, but it favors the Democratic Party, Shelby’s former political party.
This seemingly overnight flip from Republican to Democrat shows how fragile political majorities can be under certain circumstances.
Trump won Madison County by nine points in 2024. However, if you pair new voters who brought their politics with them with an overall malaise and resentment toward the current Republican administration, a county could flip in a matter of months.
At worst, Republicans could lose three or four legislative seats. Incumbent U.S. Rep. Dale Strong (R-Huntsville) could also have a long night ahead if some of the outlying boxes in his district don’t turn out.
Changing the culture and economy of a part of your state comes with a political price. Sure, you might get a windfall in tax receipts, new customers for local businesses, etc.
When the government tries to boost the local economy, as the GOP-controlled state and federal governments have, there are intended consequences, and unintended consequences can be felt across the state.